For someone who takes pride in being a practicing Catholic, I tend to grow tired of routine. However, that may also reflect a stereotypical view of Catholicism. The common perception of the Church is that it is little more than the rote repetition of certain prayers and rituals that people perform rather than live. If that were the case, then my occasional stir-craziness would make sense. Today’s film, The Land of Steady Habits (2018), discusses the ways in which predictability can affect people. How the characters handle their apparent boredom deserves criticism, but I will get into that in a moment. As I relate the synopsis, it will become clear just how wounded these people are.
The wounds beneath the comfortable surface of suburban life become apparent almost immediately in The Land of Steady Habits, which follows Anders Harris (Ben Mendelsohn), a Connecticut man who has divorced his wife, Helene Harris (Edie Falco), and retired early from his career in finance. Disgusted by the greed he associates with his former profession and restless in his marriage, Anders had hoped that abandoning both would offer a fresh start. Instead, he finds himself alone in a condominium, drifting through casual sexual encounters and struggling to understand what he actually wants. His grown son, Preston Harris (Thomas Mann), has troubles of his own. A recovering addict who graduated from Northwestern University, Preston lives with Helene in the family house and works as a reading specialist through a job she helped him obtain. Anders attends a Christmas party hosted by Helene and their neighbors, Mitchell Ashford (Michael Gaston) and Sophie Ashford (Elizabeth Marvel), but feels like an outsider among people who once formed his social circle. Outside, he joins the Ashfords’ teenage son, Charlie Ashford (Charlie Tahan), and his friends, who persuade him to smoke from a bong. Only afterward does Anders learn that the marijuana contains PCP. Charlie suffers an overdose and is rushed to the hospital, turning the gathering into a crisis. Later, Anders admits his involvement to his therapist and is surprised to discover that the therapist also attended the party. His financial circumstances are scarcely better than his personal life. Although Helene still occupies their former house, Anders remains responsible for its mortgage and has fallen six months behind on payments. He realizes that his retirement cannot support the arrangement. Seeking assistance, he approaches his friend Larry Eastwood (Josh Pais), who takes him to a strip club instead. There, Anders meets Barbara (Connie Britton), a woman whose company he enjoys, and the two share a taxi afterward. Intoxicated, Anders mistakenly gives the driver his old address and lets himself into the family house with his key, alarming Helene, Preston, and Helene’s new boyfriend, Donny O’Connell (Bill Camp). The incident only deepens the embarrassment and resentment between them. Preston soon loses his job after taking money from a man he was supposed to help and using it to gamble. He also tells Helene that Anders has not been paying the mortgage. When Preston later visits his father, he explains that he has found work delivering alcohol but has been thrown out of his mother’s house. Anders refuses to let him move into the condominium, insisting that his son must learn to take responsibility for himself. Meanwhile, Charlie, still struggling after his overdose, turns up at Anders’ home after fleeing the prospect of rehabilitation. He asks Anders to care for his pet turtle. Rather than immediately returning the boy to his parents, Anders accompanies him to a makeshift clubhouse, where they use drugs and Charlie discusses a graphic novel he is creating about Laika, the dog sent into space by the Soviet Union. Anders eventually decides to take him home, but Charlie slips away. Preston, meanwhile, delivers wine to a prosperous former classmate whose comfortable life and impending fatherhood make Preston painfully conscious of his own failures. The encounter ends badly, and his vehicle subsequently breaks down. Stranded near railroad tracks with a bottle of champagne, Preston considers drinking it, a dangerous temptation for someone trying to remain sober. Instead, he places the bottle on the tracks for a passing train to destroy. Walking back, he discovers Charlie’s lifeless body behind a tree. The tragedy brings Preston back into his mother’s household, but it leaves the families grieving and searching for explanations. On Christmas Eve, when the Harrises and Ashfords traditionally dine together, Preston finds Anders staying in a hotel and persuades him to attend. At dinner, Anders reveals that he took drugs with Charlie, provoking anger from the grieving parents. The gathering grows still more painful when Sophie reveals that Helene had been involved with Donny for two years before the divorce. Mitchell, furious at Anders’ role in Charlie’s troubles, attacks him and presses a lit cigar against his forehead. The disastrous evening lays bare the dishonesty, resentment, and grief that have been simmering beneath the families’ outwardly respectable lives. Several months later, their circumstances have changed. Helene has sold the house and is preparing to marry Donny in Hawaii. Preston has secured his own apartment and plans to attend graduate school in New York City, suggesting that he is finally finding some direction. Anders continues seeing Barbara and appears more willing to accept a quieter existence rather than fleeing from it. He is also caring for Charlie’s turtle, a small but poignant reminder of the young man whose death exposed how deeply the adults’ choices could affect others.
In the final summation of The Land of Steady Habits, the old routines have disappeared, but Anders is beginning to discover that a different life still requires responsibility toward the people around him. For most of the film, he behaves irresponsibly, sleeping with one woman after another and using drugs and alcohol in between those encounters. It is hardly the most Catholic behavior, to say the least, but it would not be particularly Catholic of me to dismiss him simply as a bad person. He certainly engages in sinful behavior, but he is no more in need of God’s mercy than the rest of us. We live in a fallen world, and none of us is free from the effects of sin. Even the saints, with the singular exception of the Blessed Virgin Mary, needed God’s saving grace; holiness does not mean that a person has never struggled or fallen. The trouble is that we tend to look at certain activities, especially drug use, and assume that they are necessarily worse in God’s eyes than the sins we find easier to overlook in ourselves. As mentioned earlier, Anders leaves his marriage because he believes his life has become devoid of meaning. The Church takes marriage seriously as a lifelong covenant, although the moral circumstances surrounding separation and civil divorce cannot be reduced to a blanket judgment. In Anders’ case, he responds to his dissatisfaction not by seeking healing but by pursuing other forms of behavior that leave him just as empty. He is searching for something that no person or passing pleasure can fully provide: the lasting fulfillment found in God. This, too, makes him little different from the rest of humanity. For all the film’s exploration of the human condition, one thing it does not fully consider, at least in this Catholic reviewer’s estimation, is that there are seasons to our lives. Ecclesiastes reminds us that there is a time for everything under heaven. Broader Western culture has embraced the language of life’s seasons while often forgetting its Scriptural roots. That is to our detriment, because the passage invites us to recognize that change, loss, and even periods of uncertainty need not mean our lives have lost their purpose. Perhaps a greater willingness to accept this truth would have helped these characters avoid some of their mistakes.
What is also unavoidable about The Land of Steady Habits is that it rambles a bit in the middle. It is never comfortable for this reviewer to watch people struggle without God, and these characters appear directionless throughout much of the film. In other words, this one is skippable.