Concrete Cowboy, by Albert W. Vogt III

If you had told me before watching Concrete Cowboy (2020) that there was a horse-riding culture in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, I would not have believed it. Philadelphia, Montana, perhaps (which does not exist), but not the City of Brotherly Love. The unexpected nature of this story goes deeper. When I think of Philadelphia’s ethnic mix, my mind goes to the south side of town, with its narrow streets and Italian roots. By the way, this is me admitting to stereotypical thinking, something I try to avoid as a Catholic. Faith is about trying to see the world through God’s eyes, recognizing that every person is made in His image and likeness, and that many of our invented distinctions are laughable to Him. Hopefully, this story will widen your gaze.

The unexpected world of Concrete Cowboy comes into view when fifteen-year-old Cole (Caleb McLaughlin) is expelled from school after repeated trouble in Detroit. His exhausted mother, Amahle (Liz Priestley), drives him to North Philadelphia and leaves him with his estranged father, Harp (Idris Elba), hoping that a change of surroundings will give him some direction. Cole is hardly reassured when he discovers that Harp spends his evenings with a group of African American horseback riders at the Fletcher Street Stables and even keeps a horse inside his house. The place is untidy, food is scarce, and Harp expects his son to follow rules rather than demand comforts. Cole immediately wants to return home. Instead, he reconnects with his older cousin Smush (Jharrel Jerome), whose easy charm and apparent independence make him more appealing than his stern father. Smush drives him around the neighborhood and buys him food, but Harp warns Cole that his cousin is dealing drugs and refuses to let him stay in the house if he continues spending time with him. Unable to find another place to sleep, Cole slips into the stables and settles into a stall occupied by a notoriously difficult horse named Boo. The next morning, a neighbor named Nessie (Lorraine Toussaint) discovers him unharmed beside the animal, surprising the riders because Boo normally will not allow anyone near him. Cole gradually becomes curious about the horses, although he soon learns that joining this community means working before riding. I would be remiss if I did not add that, as a Catholic, I am all about community. Paris (Jamil Prattis), a rider who uses a wheelchair, teaches him how to clean the stalls and explains that caring for a horse demands patience and discipline. Cole initially resents the unpleasant labor, but his growing attachment to Boo gives him a reason to continue. He also meets Esha (Ivannah-Mercedes), a young rider who helps him feel less like an outsider. Meanwhile, the older cowboys share stories about a tradition that has survived in Philadelphia for generations despite the disappearance of many neighborhood stables. Harp’s relationship with his son remains strained. Cole believes that his father cares more about the horses and the other riders than he does about his own child. During an argument, Harp admits that he once sold drugs and spent time in prison before Cole was born. He explains that he named his son after the jazz musician John Coltrane (not pictured), hoping Cole would find his own path to greatness even without his father beside him. Although the conversation gives Cole a better understanding of Harp’s past, he continues secretly meeting Smush. His cousin reveals that he once rode horses himself but turned to dealing drugs to finance a dream of buying a ranch in the West, where he imagines escaping the violence and pressure of city life. Smush invites Cole to help him earn the money, and the temptation threatens the progress the boy is making at the stables. Cole nevertheless begins to experience the rewards of his new responsibilities. When Boo escapes and runs into a neighborhood field, the riders struggle to approach him. Harp insists that Cole is the only person the frightened animal trusts. Nervously, Cole steps forward, calms Boo, and finally climbs onto his back, earning the admiration of the community and a new sense of confidence. That achievement does not end his divided loyalties. Cole accompanies Smush on a drug transaction that goes wrong when another dealer threatens them. The police arrive, and the cousins flee before they can be caught. Smush insists that they are close to having enough money to leave Philadelphia, but Cole begins to recognize that the supposed shortcut to freedom could destroy them both. Trouble also comes to Fletcher Street when animal-control officers arrive to confiscate the horses, citing complaints and concerns about their care. Harp reluctantly accepts that the authorities have the power to remove them, but Cole angrily accuses his father of giving up without a fight. Disillusioned, he returns to Smush and accompanies him on another dangerous errand. This time, violence catches up with his cousin. Smush is shot and killed, leaving Cole terrified and devastated. Cole disappears, and Harp searches until he finds his son hiding at the stables. Rather than greeting him with anger, Harp gently washes the blood from his hands and comforts him in his grief. He acknowledges that Smush belonged to their community, despite the choices that led him away from it, and insists that the young man deserves a proper farewell. Harp and the riders then devise a plan to recover the confiscated horses from the municipal facility. With help from Leroy (Clifford “Method Man” Smith), a police officer who knows the community, they enter the property at night and lead their animals away. Reunited with Boo, Cole joins the riders in a solemn procession through the neighborhood to Smush’s grave, where he places a pair of cowboy boots in remembrance of his cousin. In the cemetery, Cole manages to stand on Boo’s back, accomplishing something he once thought impossible. Their victory is bittersweet, however, because the Fletcher Street Stables are soon demolished. Harp reminds the riders that their identity and community cannot be destroyed simply by taking away a building, and they resolve to keep riding. When Amahle returns to Philadelphia, she finds a son who has begun to understand responsibility and a father who has finally connected with him. Harp thanks her for bringing Cole into his life, while Cole proudly introduces his mother to Boo and the remarkable world he has come to call home.

As I mentioned in the introduction, Concrete Cowboy introduced me to a world I did not know existed. While watching the film, I wondered whether this culture had been invented for the story, which would have been fine, too. The fact that it is real makes the movie more authentic, and as the end credits roll, we hear from actual members of the community. They include Paris and Esha, who explain how important this culture is to them. The riders have survived much over the years, as has the Catholic Church in the United States. What we see here is a small group of people devoted to a way of life that teaches its members discipline, responsibility, and care for other living creatures. To do so, Nessie reminds us, requires love. It also helps that she compares Cole to the prodigal son not long after he arrives in Philadelphia. Because that parable is so familiar, one might assume she is using the term merely in a general sense. However, she tells the teenager that he has yet to eat the pigs’ slop, recalling the moment in the Gospel when the prodigal son realizes how far he has fallen. He then resolves to return to his father, and the parallel with Cole and Harp is difficult to miss. The story is not simply about a wayward son learning discipline; it is also about a father learning to receive his son with compassion. Returning to the comparison between this community and the Church, both have faced outside pressures while striving to preserve traditions that give their members a sense of belonging. The riders’ work centers on the care of horses and the relationships formed through that responsibility. St. Francis of Assisi, with his appreciation for God’s creation, would surely find something to admire in that. Catholics in the United States likewise built communities around their parishes, often within ethnic neighborhoods, preserving traditions that helped make this country the patchwork of cultures it is today. Of course, preserving a tradition does not place it beyond criticism, and the welfare of the horses remains a genuine responsibility. Still, there is no end to the variety of God’s creation or the good that His people can accomplish through their different gifts. Communities that nurture love, responsibility, and human dignity deserve to be understood rather than casually swept aside.

One thing you can do to help preserve awareness of this culture is to watch Concrete Cowboy. There are some choices Cole makes that I would rather not see, but he learns from his mistakes and begins to accept responsibility for his life. In general, I have nothing bad to say about this one.

Leave a Reply