There are two facts about me that, when I tell people in tandem, lead them to assume that I am as square a person as has ever walked the planet: I am a practicing Catholic, and I do not drink. The latter is a personal choice, though I do not begrudge people who choose to imbibe. I worry about some of the shenanigans one sees in a movie like Wine Country (2019), but that brand of over-the-top behavior is purposeful to the story. I hope so, anyway. The assumption prompted by the former statement is laughable. The Church has played a considerable role in Western drinking culture. Next time you have a glass of champagne, thank the Benedictine order. By the way, Catholicism has nothing to do with today’s film. Just something to keep in the back of your mind as you continue reading.
The festivities are at the forefront of Wine Country, which begins when Abby (Amy Poehler) organizes a weekend in California’s Napa Valley to celebrate the fiftieth birthday of her longtime friend Rebecca (Rachel Dratch). The friends first met while working at a pizzeria, and their group includes Catherine (Ana Gasteyer), Jenny (Emily Spivey), Naomi (Maya Rudolph), and Val (Paula Pell). Rebecca insists that she does not want a fuss made over her birthday, but Abby has prepared a detailed itinerary of meals, wine tastings, and activities, leaving little room for anyone else’s wishes. Unknown to the others, Abby has recently lost her job. Each of her companions has private concerns as well. Catherine, a successful television chef, constantly receives calls about her career; Naomi, a mother of four, is avoiding a call from her doctor about genetic testing related to cancer risk; Val hopes to find romance after knee surgery; and Jenny would rather be at home than on vacation. Arriving at their rental house, the friends meet its blunt owner, Tammy (Tina Fey), who predicts that their cheerful reunion will eventually turn into drunken arguments. Abby dismisses the warning and ushers everyone toward the first evening’s expensive dinner. There, Val takes an interest in their waitress, Jade (Maya Erskine), who mentions having recently broken up with her girlfriend. The following morning, they meet Devon (Jason Schwartzman), a cook and driver who comes with the rental, and endure a tarot reading Abby has arranged. This is the least Catholic moment in the film. The reader, Lady Sunshine (Cherry Jones), makes unsettling predictions about their friendship. The group then sets off to visit vineyards, where their drinking becomes increasingly enthusiastic. Naomi takes over a microphone to sing “Eternal Flame” before falling from a piano, while Catherine repeatedly interrupts the outing to deal with business calls. Val frets over messages she has sent Jade, and Abby becomes ever more irritated whenever the others deviate from her carefully planned schedule. A disagreement over gathering everyone for a photograph finally pushes her too far. Rebecca questions why Abby has ignored her wishes for a low-key birthday, and Abby lashes out before admitting that she has lost her job. Frustrated and embarrassed, she throws away the itinerary, and the women decide to attend an art exhibition to which Jade has invited Val. The exhibition turns out to consist largely of artwork inspired by the television series The Nanny (1993–1999), baffling the older visitors. Val attempts to turn her connection with Jade into a date, only to discover that Jade believes she is there simply to purchase one of the paintings. Too embarrassed to explain, Val agrees to buy it. That night, things continue to unravel. Rebecca injures her back, and Naomi finds her in pain the next morning. Rebecca confesses that she fears growing older and is unhappy with her inattentive husband, Brian, whom her friends have never particularly liked. Determined to make the most of her birthday after all, she demands that the women resume their adventures, even if they must wheel her around in a chair. Catherine is missing for part of the day, and the others assume that she has chosen work over their friendship. Hoping to surprise Rebecca, they recreate the pizzeria where they first became friends, but Catherine arrives and angrily complains that she has once again been excluded. Naomi responds that Catherine is the one who continually withdraws from the group, then finally reveals that she has been afraid to learn the results of a test for a BRCA gene mutation associated with increased cancer risk. As Naomi storms away, Rebecca confronts Abby again, pointing out that her obsessive planning has made the birthday celebration more about Abby’s need for control than Rebecca’s happiness. Abby follows Naomi, and the others join the escalating argument outdoors. Their quarrel is interrupted when a snake bites Naomi. Unable to get a telephone signal, the women scramble for help down a hillside, repeatedly tumbling and sliding as they go. In the commotion, Rebecca’s back unexpectedly improves. Catherine announces that she has decided against a demanding new television opportunity because she wants more room in her life for the people she loves, although the others are too far away to hear her. At the hospital, the friends learn that Naomi was bitten by a nonvenomous snake. They also support her as she finally contacts her doctor and discovers that she does not carry the BRCA mutation. Val ignores another call from Jade, and the friends begin to appreciate one another’s different lives. Tammy arrives with flowers and gives them a ride back to the rental house. Rather than organizing another elaborate outing, the women invite her to join them as they relax together with wine and conversation. Abby admits that she slept with Devon, prompting Rebecca to reveal that she did, too. The friends laugh at the awkward coincidence and finally celebrate Rebecca’s fiftieth birthday without the pressure of making the weekend perfect.
The casual sexual encounters and the apparent primary purpose of the trip in Wine Country—getting drunk—make for a film containing plenty that is objectionable from a Catholic perspective. As I discussed in the introduction, there is nothing inherently wrong with a little imbibing. It is when we drink to excess, as with so many other things in life, that it becomes problematic. To say that these women’s behavior is problematic would be an understatement. One example not discussed in the synopsis is Catherine’s suggestion that they all take Molly on their first night. The others more or less vote against it, but seem open to trying it later, once they have familiarized themselves with the drug’s effects. However, arguably the worst decision they make is inviting Lady Sunshine to conduct a tarot reading. We tend to take attempts to divine the future too lightly. I would agree that, on the surface, they can seem a little ridiculous. After all, what can a set of cards drawn at random reliably tell anyone about upcoming events? Nevertheless, the Church’s objection is not based on whether a fortune-teller is persuasive or accurate. Paragraph 2116 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church states, “All forms of divination are to be rejected.” It goes on to explain that such practices express a desire to gain power over the future and contradict the trust and reverence we owe to God alone. In other words, even when people treat divination as harmless entertainment, they risk adopting a spiritual attitude that seeks control or hidden knowledge rather than trusting in God’s providence. That does not mean every tarot reading produces a supernatural encounter, but it does mean Catholics have good reason to avoid the practice altogether. Luckily, our characters are dismissive of their experience because of Lady Sunshine’s abrasive manner. Still, regardless of how such a person behaves, seeking to divine the future is not worth the spiritual risk.
I am also not sure Wine Country is worth your time. I like the actresses in it, but their behavior is almost too over-the-top to be enjoyable. I appreciate that they learn to get along better by the end of the film, but otherwise, this one is a light pass.