Watching Hollywood attempt anything historical can often be laughable, particularly in films made decades ago. Today’s movie is The Black Knight (1954), which is admittedly set during the reign of the legendary King Arthur (Anthony Bushell), but features recognizable Christian references. Its villains also include Saracens and Vikings. If King Arthur existed, he most likely lived before the emergence of Islam, making the presence of Saracens in the story a stretch, to say the least. As for the Vikings, they are depicted wearing uniforms and those stereotypical, double-horned helmets. There are a host of other problems with what I am about to tell you besides the film’s depiction of the past, so I might as well get on with this review.
The improbable adventures of The Black Knight begin at the castle of the Earl of Yeonil (Harry Andrews), where a skilled sword maker named John (Alan Ladd) is secretly in love with the earl’s daughter, Lady Linet (Patricia Medina). Linet returns his affection, but her father considers a common craftsman an unsuitable husband. When he discovers the couple together, he orders John to leave. Sir Ontzlake (André Morell), a knight serving King Arthur, suggests that John might overcome his lowly status by earning a knighthood. Meanwhile, reports of Viking attacks have troubled King Arthur’s kingdom, even as King Mark (Patrick Troughton), the ruler of neighboring Cornwall, offers to help defend it. Before John can begin his new life, raiders disguised as Vikings attack the earl’s castle. Linet’s mother is murdered, and her father is badly beaten. John pursues the attackers, but Linet mistakes his departure for cowardice. Following the men, John sees them discard their disguises and enter Camelot as honored visitors. During a Pentecost celebration (and hooray for a Catholic celebration, I suppose), he publicly accuses the Saracen knight Sir Palamides (Peter Cushing) of directing the raid and his supposedly mute servant Bernard (Bill Brandon) of killing the earl’s wife. King Arthur is skeptical, especially because Bernard is believed to be unable to speak. John faces imprisonment, but Sir Ontzlake invokes the custom allowing a petitioner to request a favor during the feast. King Arthur grants John three months to prove his charges, warning that failure will cost him his life. Unknown to the court, Sir Palamides and King Mark are conspiring to overthrow King Arthur, using staged Viking raids to weaken his rule. Bernard’s silence is part of their deception, and Sir Palamides is furious that the servant spoke during the assault. King Arthur visits the devastated castle, where Linet cares for her injured father and refuses to hear John’s explanation. Back at Camelot, an attempt on King Arthur’s life increases the danger. John tries to enter the knights’ training school, but Sir Palamides humiliates him, so Sir Ontzlake undertakes his instruction privately. After weeks of hard training, the older knight gives John a horse and armor once worn by Sir Lancelot. John alters the armor into a black suit and begins riding anonymously as the Black Knight. He defeats Sir Hal (Basil Appleby) in a joust, attracting the king’s attention and Sir Palamides’ suspicion. Yet when Sir Palamides deliberately provokes him in Linet’s presence, John follows Sir Ontzlake’s advice to avoid a reckless confrontation. Linet again interprets his restraint as cowardice. The conspiracy takes a more sinister turn when King Mark returns for the dedication of a Christian church. Neither he nor Sir Palamides welcomes the growing influence of Christianity, and King Mark arranges another attack by men masquerading as Vikings. Several monks are killed, while Linet and surviving clergymen are abducted and taken to Stonehenge for a pagan sacrifice. The Black Knight rides to summon King Arthur’s forces, and the king’s men arrive in time to rescue the captives and destroy the sacrificial site. Linet discovers that her rescuer is John, and the lovers are reconciled. Sir Palamides, however, has not abandoned his ambitions. He kidnaps Linet to force her to reveal the Black Knight’s identity and orders Bernard to torture her when she refuses. John arrives to rescue her and hears Bernard cry out after Linet attacks him with a knife, apparently proving that the servant can speak. Unfortunately, Linet faints and cannot corroborate what John heard. Sir Ontzlake warns that the Black Knight’s secret identity will not protect him much longer and urges him to obtain evidence of King Mark’s treason. With help from someone inside King Mark’s castle, John sneaks in and overhears the conspirators planning an invasion of Camelot while arranging to blame the Black Knight for the raids. Sir Palamides then produces the Black Knight’s shield at King Arthur’s court and denounces its owner as a traitor. John appears in his black armor, only to be arrested and imprisoned. Linet helps him escape, allowing him to warn Sir Ontzlake about the imminent attack. John then infiltrates King Mark’s stronghold and forces the king to return to Camelot. On the morning of the planned invasion, Sir Palamides instructs Bernard to murder King Arthur. Bernard enters the king’s chamber and stabs a figure lying in bed, but it turns out to be King Mark. Bernard then speaks aloud in triumph over Sir Palamides’ supposed victory. King Arthur, John, and the knights are hiding nearby and hear the confession, exposing the supposedly mute servant and clearing John of the accusations against him. With the conspiracy revealed, King Arthur leads his forces against the attacking raiders and drives them away. John’s loyalty and courage are finally recognized when King Arthur formally makes him a knight and gives his blessing for John to marry Linet.
Thus, after an astonishing collection of disguises, mistaken identities, and improbable historical encounters, the sword maker wins both his place at court and the woman he loves, and The Black Knight comes full circle. There is also a tiring number of shots featuring riders arriving at one castle or another. It is like watching a medieval version of a daily commute. Then again, using the word “medieval” in connection with this film is difficult for someone with even a passing knowledge of history. If King Arthur existed, some historians have speculated that he lived around the time of the Roman withdrawal from Britain in the fifth century. However, that is not how the popular imagination pictures him and his fabled Knights of the Round Table at Camelot. I would say that this persistent anachronism is a product of the 1950s, but films from every era struggle to get historical settings right, assuming the setting is historical in the first place. Somewhat less objectionable is the film’s depiction of Christianity spreading through the British Isles. At the end of the sixth century, St. Augustine of Canterbury arrived in Kent with monks sent by Pope St. Gregory the Great to evangelize the Anglo-Saxons. I would hesitate to say “re-establish” the Faith without qualification, because Christianity had existed in Roman Britain and survived in parts of the island after Roman rule ended. However, the arrival of the Anglo-Saxons had dramatically changed the religious landscape of what became England. The conversion of King Æthelberht of Kent was an important early development in the mission, and Christianity gradually spread through the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms. Of note in the film is the dedication of a new church, attended by King Arthur. It is also fitting, at least in a broad historical sense, that the church is attacked by warriors posing as Vikings, since Viking raiders did attack religious communities centuries later. The trouble is that the film throws these events and peoples into one fantastical historical blender. The result looks especially ridiculous because it reflects the way such figures were commonly depicted in 1950s adventure films. Still, the Church’s endurance through centuries of upheaval is a much more interesting story than the movie’s muddled chronology suggests.
I would hope that if The Black Knight were made today, it would look much better than this turkey. Then again, the title character does have a Batman-esque flavor, sans the wealth. Instead, his status is earned through good deeds, which is nice, but the same idea can be found in better packages.