Greenfingers, by Albert W. Vogt III

One of the corporal works of mercy according to the Catholic Church is visiting the imprisoned. This does not receive enough attention, mainly because we tend to take our freedom for granted. For those serving time behind bars, whether guilty of a crime or wrongfully convicted, our lives on the proverbial outside must feel like an unattainable dream. Put differently, it is easy to lose hope. Whatever we might think about the incarcerated, and regardless of their degree of contrition, they are human beings endowed by God with the same dignity and fundamental desires as the rest of us. Their circumstances may obscure that truth for a time, but their humanity remains. We see these themes in today’s film, Greenfingers (2000), a surprising little movie that I am happy to bring you.

The promise of renewal in Greenfingers begins when Colin Briggs (Clive Owen), a withdrawn prisoner serving a sentence for murder, is transferred to HMP Edgefield, an experimental open prison in the English countryside. Its inmates enjoy greater freedom of movement and opportunities to work, but Colin has little interest in making friends or planning for life beyond his sentence. He shares a room with Fergus Wilks (David Kelly), an elderly prisoner who tends a plant and insists that even a bleak environment can support new life. When Fergus becomes ill, Colin reluctantly looks after the plant. At Christmas, Fergus gives him a packet of violet seeds, which Colin plants in a barren patch of ground largely to silence his persistent roommate. Against expectations, the flowers flourish. Their appearance causes an argument among the inmates, but prison governor Gerald Hodge (Warren Clarke) sees an opportunity. He assigns Colin and Fergus to establish a proper garden alongside three other prisoners: Tony (Danny Dyer), Raw (Adam Fogerty), and Jimmy (Paterson Joseph). The men initially regard the work as an embarrassment, but they gradually take pride in preparing the soil, choosing plants, and transforming the neglected grounds. Colin proves especially gifted, and gardening gives him something he has lacked for years: a reason to look toward the future. News of their achievement reaches Georgina Woodhouse (Helen Mirren), a prominent horticultural expert who visits Edgefield with her daughter, Primrose Woodhouse (Natasha Little). Georgina is impressed by the prisoners’ ingenuity and becomes their enthusiastic champion, arguing that they deserve to exhibit a garden at the prestigious Hampton Court Palace Flower Show. She also helps arrange outside gardening work for the men at a private estate. During these excursions, Colin and Primrose grow attracted to one another, although his conviction and uncertain prospects make their romance difficult. Georgina supports the gardening project but is considerably less comfortable with the possibility of her daughter becoming involved with a convicted murderer. Meanwhile, the proposal to enter the flower show faces resistance from officials who doubt that prisoners should receive such an opportunity. Just as the men begin to believe they might compete, a valuable tapestry disappears from the estate where they have been working. Suspicion falls on the inmates, particularly Tony, who flees, and the authorities withdraw permission for their entry. The setback threatens the confidence the gardeners have painstakingly developed. Colin nevertheless appears before a parole board and explains that tending plants has changed how he thinks about responsibility and the future. His application succeeds, giving him the freedom he once seemed incapable of imagining. Before leaving, he confides in Fergus about the crime that brought him to prison: at eighteen, he killed his younger brother in a fit of rage after discovering that the brother had been involved with the woman Colin intended to marry. The confession reveals the terrible guilt beneath Colin’s reserve and deepens the bond between the two men. After his release, Colin stays at the Woodhouse estate and begins a relationship with Primrose, to Georgina’s alarm. Eventually, the missing tapestry is recovered and the prisoners are cleared of involvement in its theft, allowing the Hampton Court invitation to be restored. Colin should now be able to build a life outside Edgefield, but news arrives that Fergus is seriously ill. Determined to return to his friends and help complete the garden, Colin deliberately commits a minor theft, taking yellow roses from a florist and leaving them for Primrose as a painful farewell. He is sent back to prison, where the team is preparing its exhibition under official supervision. A visiting government minister insists that the prisoners construct a bleak rock garden meant to symbolize confinement, rather than the vibrant design they would prefer. Colin resents the decision, which seems to reduce the men once again to their criminal records. Then Fergus dies, devastating the group and depriving Colin of the friend who first taught him to nurture something living. In grief and anger, Colin burns the imposed rock garden, forcing the men to begin again. They use the opportunity to create a flourishing display that reflects their own experience of change rather than an outsider’s notion of imprisonment. At Hampton Court, Colin scatters Fergus’s ashes among the plants, honoring the man whose faith in him made the transformation possible. Georgina arranges for Primrose to see Colin, and the couple reconcile. He asks whether she will wait until his next release, and she agrees. Although the Edgefield entry fails to win an official prize, Governor Hodge tells the men how proud he is of their accomplishment. Their efforts receive an unexpected endorsement when Queen Elizabeth II requests a private meeting and indicates that she believes the judges have overlooked something remarkable.

Greenfingers closes by noting that the real prisoners whose experiences inspired the story went on to earn prestigious gardening awards, a reminder that an unexpected talent can take root even behind prison walls. It may seem like an absurd premise, but the film is based on a true story. The idea is that, if incarceration is truly meant to be reformative, people need a purpose. I appreciate this notion especially in Colin. Here is a man who, as discussed in the introduction, has little hope. Part of the reason is that nobody comes to visit him. Having killed his brother, Colin has been disowned by the rest of his family, and the movie underscores how deeply this isolation contributes to his lack of interest in doing anything. If nobody is coming to see him, the next best thing is to give him meaningful work. He is also blessed with companionship in the form of Fergus, whose patience and kindness help him recognize that his life still has value. There is another Catholic dimension to the inmates’ activities. Colin and his fellow prisoners rightly object to the dehumanizing nature of the rock garden they are ordered to submit for the Hampton Court show. It reduces them to their status as prisoners, as though their crimes were the only things worth knowing about them. In other words, instead of recognizing them as people created in God’s image, the system risks treating them as uniformed numbers who will remain nothing more until they are free. From a Catholic perspective, I therefore appreciate what Gerald is trying to accomplish at Edgefield. At one point, he argues that harsher prisons are associated with a greater likelihood of reoffending, a concern that extends well beyond England to the United States. Rather than treating punishment and rehabilitation as mutually exclusive, his purpose is to give the inmates a structured measure of freedom that will prepare them to return to society. The Church likewise insists that punishment should protect the common good while leaving room for repentance, rehabilitation, and the restoration of the offender. Gerald does not excuse the prisoners’ crimes, nor should we. Instead, he recognizes that a person can be held accountable for wrongdoing without being stripped of his God-given dignity. Put another way, he sees them in something approaching the way God sees all of us: as human beings of enduring worth, capable of growth and deserving of mercy.

Because Greenfingers has such a positive message, I say that this one is worth your time. You will have to deal with some colorful language and brief nudity, but nothing that is particularly over-the-top. Rather, you have someone learning the value of life by helping to tend other living things.

Leave a Reply