Honestly, I did not watch the entirety of The Hunger Games a few months back with the intention of preparing for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the latest installment in this interminable saga. Indeed, having watched the other installments, I hoped that those five would be it and that they would not make any more. I also vow before you and God that I had no idea this was coming out until, not long after concluding the series to that point, I saw the trailer for this one. Since then, I have also heard rumors that they are going to produce more, and that they are making poor Jennifer Lawrence reprise her role as Katniss Everdeen, the protagonist of the original four. Sigh. I just pray for a pleasant theater experience whenever I go to the cinema, and I do feel bad when I have to be critical. So, here you go.
The latest ordeal in Panem that is The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping begins not with Katniss Everdeen but with the boy who will eventually become her embittered mentor. Sixteen-year-old Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) celebrates his birthday in District 12 with his family and his girlfriend, Lenore Dove Baird (Whitney Peak), knowing that the annual reaping could destroy their future. This is the fiftieth Hunger Games, the Second Quarter Quell, for which President Coriolanus Snow (Ralph Fiennes) has ordered twice the usual number of tributes. At the ceremony, Capitol escort Drusilla Sickle (Glenn Close) lashes out at Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace), and a selected boy, Woodbine Chance (Serafin Mishiev), is shot while attempting to escape. Haymitch intervenes when Peacekeepers threaten Lenore Dove and is forced to take the dead boy’s place. Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons) restages the selection for the cameras, concealing the government’s brutality. Haymitch departs with Maysilee, Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang), and Louella McCoy (Molly McCann), leaving Lenore Dove with a promise to return. In the Capitol, the children are treated as entertainment, and the spectacle turns deadly when smoke grenades disrupt their chariot parade. Louella is killed in the chaos, yet officials replace her with a girl called Lou Lou (Iona Bell), whose altered appearance and erased memories allow the broadcast to pretend nothing happened. Haymitch openly mocks Snow, earning the president’s attention and threats against those he loves. He encounters former victors Beetee Latier (Kelvin Harrison Jr.), Wiress (Maya Hawke), and Mags Flanagan (Lili Taylor), who are involved in a clandestine attempt to undermine the arena. Beetee provides Haymitch with information for the operation, while Plutarch’s ambiguous encouragement suggests that opposition exists even within the Capitol. Haymitch must decide whether merely surviving is enough when the Games themselves might be sabotaged. The contrast between the lavish Capitol and the frightened children from the districts is impossible to ignore. Every smile demanded for the cameras disguises a threat, and every apparent kindness comes with an expectation of obedience. Even the mentors know that challenging the spectacle could cost their families dearly. The contrast between the lavish Capitol and the frightened children from the districts is impossible to ignore. Every smile demanded for the cameras disguises a threat, and every apparent kindness comes with an expectation of obedience. Even the mentors know that challenging the spectacle could cost their families dearly. The arena initially resembles a beautiful valley, but its streams, plants, and animals conceal lethal dangers. At the opening bloodbath, numerous tributes die, including Wyatt, killed by an axe thrown by Silka Sharp (Laura Marcus). Haymitch separates from his temporary allies and learns that even the water is poisonous. Watching animals suffer gives him clues about the hazards, and he uses charcoal to counteract toxins. Other tributes fall to engineered creatures, including electrifying butterflies and deadly swarms. Haymitch encounters Ampert Latier (Percy Daggs IV), Beetee’s young son, but cannot save him from vicious squirrel-like mutts. The mounting deaths leave him exhausted and increasingly desperate to strike back at the system responsible. At the arena’s boundary, he discovers an invisible force field that rebounds objects hurled against it. A volcanic eruption adds another manufactured catastrophe, and Haymitch narrowly survives with severe injuries. His persistence reflects a Catholic moral distinction between enduring suffering and accepting the injustice that causes it. Maysilee later rescues him from dangerous opponents, and together they investigate the equipment supporting the arena’s defenses. Their alliance ends when a swarm of monstrous birds fatally attacks her, leaving Haymitch as District 12’s final surviving tribute. He hears the familiar ringing bell carried by another contestant, but the sound is a trap set by Silka. During their confrontation at the arena’s edge, Silka throws her axe at him. Haymitch dodges, allowing the weapon to ricochet off the force field and kill her instead. With every other tribute dead, he has won the Games, but he refuses to leave without attempting his larger mission. He detonates an improvised explosive against the force-field generator, hoping to damage the arena, and collapses. Although he survives, the Capitol suppresses his defiance. Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin) presents manipulated footage depicting Haymitch as a selfish coward who abandoned his companions, rather than a young man who tried to challenge the Games. The official story erases both his courage and the deaths that might expose the regime’s cruelty. Returning to District 12 brings still worse punishment. Snow’s agents have burned Haymitch’s home, killing his mother, Willamae Abernathy (Kara Tointon), and younger brother, Sid Abernathy (Smylie Bradwell). His reunion with Lenore Dove ends tragically when a poisoned sweet planted by Snow kills her. Before dying, she urges him to prevent future reapings. Shattered by these losses, Haymitch retreats into isolation and alcohol, seemingly becoming the bitter man audiences will recognize from the earlier films. Plutarch nevertheless visits him and insists that the resistance has not ended with one failed attempt. Haymitch gradually accepts that he can continue opposing the Capitol by mentoring future tributes and supporting the longer struggle for freedom. Years later, after Snow’s regime has fallen, an older Haymitch (Woody Harrelson) shares a peaceful moment with Katniss and Peeta Mellark (Josh Hutcherson), suggesting that the sacrifices of his youth were not entirely in vain.
What is also vain is expecting The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping to have any outcome other than the one you see. It is ironic, too, because the film is heavy-handed in trying to make you think that Haymitch might not survive. To be fair, this is the problem with prequel characters, especially in action-packed stories. Throughout the movie, Lenore Dove’s admonition that nothing is inevitable keeps being mentioned. As a Catholic and a reviewer, I must take issue with this phrase. Again, in the context of the film and the franchise to which it belongs, we already know that Haymitch lives. He appears in the first four installments as his older self, training Katniss and Peeta for their own turn in the arena and helping to lead the rebellion against President Snow. As such, during every harrowing moment, including the final showdown with Silka, we already know the outcome. The only mystery is how it happens, but for this critic, it makes for a yawn-fest of a cinematic experience. You can have all the death-defying stunts, beautiful shots, and incredible action sequences, but if you know ahead of time that the person in question will come through it in one piece, how exciting is it, really? The opposite is true when it comes to faith. The Bible assures us that the ultimate triumph belongs to God. The task left to us is to worship Him with all our hearts, souls, and strength. By doing so, we can trust in His ultimate victory, even though our individual paths and earthly outcomes are not assured.
To be assured of anything is a rare commodity in a movie like The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, though I guess those behind the camera cannot be blamed for the inevitability. For whatever reason, people want to watch these films. Even though I am not a fan of the franchise, I was reminded of something my dad often said to me when I was a child: when Haymitch is about to enter the arena, Effie Trinket (Elle Fanning) tells him to have a positive attitude. It is a strange bit of advice, considering he is about to face life-or-death situations, but it does have some Christian overtones. To return to the discussion about inevitability from the last paragraph, knowing of God’s ultimate plan for His creation can give us some confidence. It is stated more poetically by Lenore Dove. Before Haymitch is chosen, they have a discussion in which the topic of death comes up. Her philosophical outlook is that people do not die; they simply transition to another realm of existence. To be sure, this sounds like the kind of New Age belief to which the Church cautions against giving credence. It is interesting, though, because her words speak to the innate human desire to understand what will happen to us in the afterlife. Catholicism tells us that what people are really looking for is God. You might think that such concerns would be far removed from this story, and yet we know that it takes place in a world in which Edgar Allan Poe (not pictured) existed, so why not Christianity? That it does not exist in dystopian fantasy land seems like a miss.
What I could not miss as I was booking my ticket for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping was how highly rated this film was on Rotten Tomatoes. I do not get it, particularly when you factor in the inevitability of Haymitch’s survival. Yet we had to sit through two and a half hours just to get to where we knew we were going all along. Pass.