Dumplin’, by Albert W. Vogt III

One would be hard-pressed to find someone who did not like the late Dolly Parton (not pictured). The unfortunate aspect of her nearly universal acclaim is that, in the wake of her recent passing, people from across the political spectrum have tried to claim her as their own. If certain groups want to make the case that the famous country singer supported their cause, I wonder what they would think of Dumplin’ (2018). As a practicing Catholic, I appreciate the working-class Parton of 9 to 5 (1980), an entertainer with whom the downtrodden of the world could identify, much as the Church identifies with them. Dumplin’ presents a different side of Parton’s influence, and all I can do is tell you about it.

The different side of Dolly Parton’s influence in Dumplin’ emerges through Willowdean Dickson (Danielle Macdonald), a Texas teenager whose mother, Rosie Dickson (Jennifer Aniston), is a former beauty queen devoted to organizing the town’s Miss Teen Bluebonnet Pageant. Rosie calls her daughter “Dumplin’,” a nickname Willowdean dislikes, particularly because she is already self-conscious about her weight. Rosie’s devotion to the pageant leaves her daughter feeling that appearances matter more to her mother than their relationship. The contrast is particularly painful because Willowdean remembers a different sort of affection from the woman who encouraged her throughout childhood. She was largely raised by her aunt, Lucy Dickson (Hilliary Begley), who taught her to love Parton’s music and to value herself without seeking approval from others. Lucy died six months earlier, leaving Willowdean grieving and increasingly distant from her mother. Her closest companion is Ellen Dryver (Odeya Rush), whom Lucy introduced to her when they were children. At school, Willowdean defends another heavyset student, Millie Michalchuk (Maddie Baillio), from a bully and is suspended. An argument with Rosie afterward deepens their estrangement, especially when Rosie criticizes Lucy’s health. While sorting through her aunt’s belongings, Willowdean discovers that Lucy once completed an application for the very pageant Rosie now directs. Realizing that Lucy never entered, she decides to compete herself as a protest against narrow ideas of beauty. Ellen joins her, as do Millie, who sincerely dreams of participating, and Hannah Perez (Bex Taylor-Klaus), whose feminist objections make the competition an unlikely choice. Rosie believes her daughter intends to ridicule an event that means a great deal to her and warns that entering will require genuine effort. Willowdean, however, is determined to challenge expectations. She also finds herself drawn to Bo Larson (Luke Benward), a coworker at the local diner. Bo invites her to watch a meteor shower, and they kiss, but she panics when he touches her back, fearing that he will judge her body. She pulls away despite his evident affection. The pageant meanwhile begins to complicate Willowdean’s friendship with Ellen, who enjoys preparing for the competition and befriends other contestants. Willowdean resents her enthusiasm and grows particularly uncomfortable with Rosie’s attention to the seemingly ideal contestant Bekah Colter (Dove Cameron). When Willowdean tells Ellen to abandon the pageant, the friends quarrel. Looking for a connection to Lucy, Willowdean finds a flyer advertising a Dolly Parton-themed drag show at a bar her aunt once frequented. The girls initially feel out of place, but the entertainers’ warmth soon replaces their uneasiness. Their visit also reveals that Lucy had found friends and acceptance in a setting Willowdean never knew existed. She visits with Millie and Hannah and meets performer Lee Wayne (Harold Perrineau), who remembers Lucy fondly. Lee’s welcoming circle gives the girls a glimpse of how much Lucy meant to people outside their family. Their preparations nevertheless remain uneven. At the pageant’s talent auditions, Willowdean’s proposed magic trick goes badly, reinforcing her fear that she does not belong onstage. Bo later tells her that he likes her and has turned down Bekah’s invitation to a school dance, but Willowdean doubts his sincerity. Hurt by her mistrust, he points out that she seems more concerned about other people’s opinions than his own feelings. Willowdean eventually returns to the childhood space she shared with Lucy and Ellen, where memories of their friendship and a treasured brooch help her reconsider why she entered the contest. Rather than treating the pageant only as an opportunity to embarrass its organizers, she decides to make a genuine effort. Lee and his fellow performers coach Willowdean, Millie, and Hannah in stage presence and performance. During a preliminary event, Willowdean delivers a speech about loyalty that moves Rosie and helps repair her friendship with Ellen. Mother and daughter also begin talking honestly about Lucy, and Rosie admits that, in urging Willowdean to give away her aunt’s belongings, she had tried too hard to push aside their shared grief. On pageant night, Millie’s mother discovers that her daughter entered without permission and confronts her, but Millie stands up for herself. Willowdean performs a magic act incorporating a tribute to Dolly Parton, winning enthusiastic applause and making Rosie proud. Yet she has altered her approved costume and music, violating the rules, and accepts disqualification rather than asking her mother for special treatment. When Ellen’s escort cannot appear for the formalwear presentation, Rosie suggests that Willowdean accompany her, allowing the reunited friends to take the stage together. Bekah wins the crown, while Millie earns first runner-up, a triumph for someone others had underestimated. Although Willowdean receives no official recognition, her willingness to participate wholeheartedly has changed both her understanding of the pageant and her relationship with her mother. Willowdean leaves to find Bo, acknowledges her fears, and shares another kiss with him. Finally, she and her friends bring Rosie and Millie’s mother to the drag bar, celebrating Lucy’s memory and the unexpected community that helped Willowdean find confidence in herself.

The confidence that Willowdean, and Millie to a degree, find by the end of Dumplin’ is as good a source of Catholic material as I can find, cinematically speaking, to fill out this review. I could also discuss the obvious lessons about loving yourself regardless of your body’s shape. To that end, there is a powerful moment when Ellen and Willowdean appear onstage together during the pageant’s swimsuit competition with the words “EVERY BODY IS A SWIMSUIT BODY” taped onto their clothing. The underlying truth is that our dignity comes from God, who created each of us in His image and likeness. That dignity is not determined by our weight, our appearance, or anyone else’s approval. This is not meant as an attack on people who wear makeup or want to lose some weight. What a Christian should consider when doing such things is the reason for doing them, and whose approval is being sought. God does not ask us to impress others through external factors like the label on our shirt or whether we have applied mascara in the correct manner, whatever that means. He sees beyond appearances and knows what is in our hearts. What He desires is that we give our hearts to Him fully. Doing that becomes more difficult when we are overly concerned with the opinions of others. We should certainly be sensitive to their needs, but living according to how we imagine they see us is a recipe for disaster. It takes Willowdean most of the film to realize that she has been doing precisely what she claims not to believe in: allowing others to dictate how she behaves. Faith teaches that, through all life’s trials, the ultimate audience whose judgment matters is an audience of One. Better still, His love is not something we earn by meeting somebody else’s standards of beauty. Our response should be to love and worship Him, not to spend our lives chasing the approval of the crowd. This includes beauty pageants.

At the same time, Dumplin’ does not portray beauty pageants as being as exploitative as modern culture sometimes makes them out to be. I am not sure I was convinced, but I can appreciate a nuanced discussion. As such, you could do worse than watching this one.

Leave a Reply