They say that variety is the spice of life. As a practicing Catholic, I can appreciate this cliché. After all, there is no limit to God, and His creation seems to mirror that fact. I can apply this logic to my movie watching as well. If you pay attention to cinema, you will notice that there are only a few basic types of stories. This is also true of the ways they are told. Thus, we should appreciate attempts to break those molds. At the same time, not every variation from the norm is good. For example, critics lauded Wheelman (2017). For this critic, it is little more than an hour and fifteen minutes of a guy driving around making phone calls.
The driving and telephone calls that dominate Wheelman begin when an unnamed getaway driver (Frank Grillo), recently released from prison, collects a BMW for a nighttime bank robbery. He has accepted the job to repay a criminal debt, although his greater concern is his teenage daughter, Katie (Caitlin Carmichael), who calls as he prepares for the assignment. His relationship with Katie’s mother, Jessica (Wendy Moniz), is strained, and he hopes to remain part of their daughter’s life. Unable to reach Clayton “Clay” (Garret Dillahunt), the associate who arranged the robbery, he collects two armed men and takes them to the bank. He refuses to tell the robbers his name, identifying himself only as the title character. While they are inside, a mysterious caller known as the Handler instructs him to wait until the stolen money is loaded into the trunk and then abandon the robbers. According to the caller, the men intend to kill their driver after the job. When the robbers emerge and deposit the bags, Wheelman speeds away without them, taking $230,000 and immediately making himself a target. The Handler orders him to count the money and follow further instructions, while an unknown caller repeatedly tries to reach him. Threatening messages arrive, and a motorcyclist begins following his car. Clay finally answers his telephone, but Wheelman suspects that his supposed friend has betrayed him. The Handler directs him to a meeting where the money is supposedly to be delivered, only for Wheelman to discover that he is being drawn into a drug transaction. He flees rather than surrender the cash. The Handler responds with threats, and the pursuing motorcyclist opens fire. Wheelman narrowly escapes, using his driving skills to lose the attacker on the city streets. Meanwhile, Jessica leaves an angry message about his failure to meet his responsibilities as a father, unaware that his criminal associates are closing in. Determined to learn who arranged the double-cross, Wheelman finds Clay and forces him into the car at gunpoint. The unknown caller reaches him again and accuses both men of stealing money that belongs to him. Another vehicle attacks them, but Wheelman manages to escape with Clay still beside him. Under pressure, Clay finally explains the scheme. The robbery was originally organized for the West End criminal gang, whose members protected Wheelman’s family during his imprisonment. Clay, however, accepted money from the leader of a rival Philadelphia organization to redirect the proceeds. The man calling himself the Handler represents that rival gang, while the other caller is the West End leader demanding his property. Wheelman realizes that he has been caught between two dangerous groups, neither of which is likely to forgive a mistake. He decides to return the money to the West End gang and tells Clay to leave town. Clay fears that he will be killed regardless and suddenly draws a gun on the driver. During the confrontation, Clay accidentally shoots himself in the head, leaving Wheelman alone with the consequences of the failed robbery. The Philadelphia leader then threatens Jessica and Katie, turning the dispute over stolen money into a desperate effort to protect his family. Wheelman telephones Katie and tells her to meet him at a parking garage. He also tries to warn Jessica, but hears her being abducted during their call. The West End leader agrees to help him recover his family, provided that Wheelman arranges a meeting that will expose the rival gang. Wheelman contacts the Philadelphia leader and negotiates a handover, although he has no intention of trusting him. One of the abandoned bank robbers finds Wheelman and attacks him, forcing the driver to fight for his life. Wheelman kills the assailant and discovers a tracking device hidden among the stolen cash. He removes the money and sets the BMW ablaze, hoping to prevent his enemies from following him any longer. Katie arrives at the garage driving her father’s Porsche, despite being too young to have any business undertaking such a dangerous errand. Wheelman instructs her to go to her uncle’s home and wait for news of Jessica, but she refuses to abandon him completely. Here, at least, a Catholic might recognize a father’s duty to protect his child, however badly he has compromised that responsibility. Katie follows him to the upper level of the garage, where the Philadelphia gang arrives with Jessica as a hostage. Wheelman distracts the criminals with a makeshift firebomb, giving Jessica an opportunity to escape. Katie drives up to collect her father, and he takes the wheel again, leading the pursuing gangsters toward the ambush arranged by the West End organization. The rival criminals are trapped, and the West End leader executes the Philadelphia boss. Wheelman hands over the stolen money, finally settling the immediate dispute. He then drives away with Katie and brings her to a restaurant where Jessica is waiting. As mother and daughter embrace, Wheelman watches their reunion, having survived the night but with his troubled choices and uncertain future still hanging over him.
Hence, Wheelman is different not only because it takes place mostly inside one car, but also because it has an open-ended conclusion. I understand what the filmmakers were attempting with the first of these storytelling choices, even if I found it dull. Sure, exciting action sequences unfold, but the camera rarely strays from inside the vehicle. As for the second aspect, I prefer a more definitive resolution. Again, Wheelman is left sitting in his car. Does he go inside? Is he arrested? A Catholic response to that last hypothetical would be that he probably should face justice for his crimes. It is not good for a father to be separated from his family, but neither does fatherhood excuse his participation in criminal activity. The Church teaches that wrongdoing calls for accountability, even as justice should leave room for repentance and rehabilitation. All the same, I am not sure what else to say about this film from a Catholic perspective. Beyond his problematic attempts to be a good dad, his raison d’être for doing what he is doing is to repay criminals for protecting his family while he was incarcerated. So, the solution is to commit more crimes? The Church, and common decency, would say no. A good intention does not make an immoral means acceptable, no matter how desperately Wheelman wants to protect his daughter.
I also say no to watching Wheelman, unless your idea of good cinema is spending an hour and change watching someone drive and talk on the phone. Yes, there are moments when he is going fast and exciting things are happening. For me, though, I need more of a story before I can call a film enjoyable.